home | news l

Much more than a simple gesture

5 February 2008 - Some people think that saying sorry is merely a gesture. The evidence shows it is in fact much more than that. I believe that forced removal from family or land is one of the most important factors leading to the modern indigenous circumstance.

Our institute's researchers interviewed more than 2100 carers of 5300 Aboriginal children across the whole state in the early 2000s. More than 40 per cent of Aboriginal children in Western Australia are living in households today where at least one carer had been affected by forced separation from their natural family or forced relocation from traditional country or homeland. These are substantial proportions for any population and while we hear of individual stories of some people surviving these traumas with apparently little harm, and some having successful educational experiences, the impact, as assessed in our research, has on the whole been grim and has moved across generations.

Carers who had been forcibly separated from their natural families were more likely to have been arrested or charged with an offence, abused alcohol or gambled to the point where it caused problems in the household, and to have used mental health services. Just as damning, children whose parents had been forcibly separated from their natural family by a mission, government or welfare agency were over twice as likely to have clinically significant emotional or behavioural difficulties.

Our scientific findings establish with firm evidence the veracity of the experience that Aboriginal people so eloquently told us in their individual stories from the Bringing Them Home Report of the National Inquiry into the Separation of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Children from Their Families.

Both of these kinds of data provide direct evidence of the impact of forced removal on the present poor health and mental health status of many Aboriginal people. Many reports suggest that the forcible removal of children from family and land was a human rights breach of enormous proportions and recommends strongly that restorative justice and healing be implemented. The lack of implementation of these recommendations should be a source of anger and indignation. That they were not acted upon perpetuates a cycle of damage and dissipates focus and energy needed for the future.

More globally, the Canadians have apologised for the Residential School program: a similar attempt to take away culture, language and family from their indigenous populations. As part of the reparation, 10 years ago they also established an Aboriginal Healing Foundation to fund a range of projects which enabled healing, cultural strengthening and other activities to acknowledge the value of the First Nations people of Canada. The results in terms of falling suicide rates and other improved outcomes have just been published.

If people realise that there are reasons for their problems that can be addressed, then they have hope enough to live and make a go of their lives. If no one appears to understand that these traumas were real and powerful influences on health and wellbeing, then why not just drown your sorrows in alcohol and try to forget? I strongly suggest that we establish a Healing Foundation immediately and monitor its effects.

The Bringing them Home Report of 1997 was strong about an apology for this aspect of our history. The report realised the power and importance of indigenous healing, along with preventive and primary mental health and wellbeing services. Such services also include parenting and family wellbeing programs, acknowledging that not having had parents at crucial stages of child and youth development meant that many Aboriginal parents were not competent or confident when they became parents themselves. Services to treat and rehabilitate those with mental illness and substance abuse were also recommended.

Perhaps the hope in avoiding an apology is the hope that saying "get over it" would be a practical solution for restorative justice, at home and in the eyes of world. However, the real harm and ongoing consequences of past policies and practices that we have documented call for reparation. Saying sorry is the starting point in creating a restorative vision for all Australians. We need to get on with saying sorry now.

Source: The Australian

Further information: stolen generations issues page - includes news index and external links

|| click to go to the top of this page